towardia Where things come from.
🌐 en

Pilgrims Choice Cheddar

Cheese range ✔ Checked: 10.2026 · sources: 2 Updated:

Pilgrims Choice Cheddar is the cheddar range of Pilgrims Choice: Mild, Mature, Extra Mature and Vintage in blocks, grated and sliced.

Pilgrims Choice Cheddar is the core range of the British brand Pilgrims Choice, owned by the Irish co-operative Ornua. It is cheddar, a hard cow's milk cheese graded by how long it has matured.

The range has four steps: Mild, mellow and creamy; Mature, smooth and full-flavoured; Extra Mature, rich and creamy with crunchy crystals; and Vintage, the longest-aged, with deep savoury flavour and a sweet edge. All come as blocks, and Extra Mature is also sold grated and sliced.

The crunchy white crystals in aged cheddar are calcium lactate, formed during maturing; the brand explains they signal a well-developed flavour. According to Pilgrims Choice, all its ingredients are suitable for vegetarians.

How to use: Mild for children, sandwiches and gentle sauces; Mature and Extra Mature for toasties, bakes, pasta and omelettes; Vintage for a cheese board with apples and chutney.

Why it matters to you: when a recipe calls for strong cheddar, choose Extra Mature or Vintage; you get more flavour from less cheese.

Facts

Raw materialcow's milk
Main usetoasties, bakes, pasta, cheese board
CountryUnited Kingdom

What it includes

kind ofPilgrims Choicekind ofPilgrims Choice M…kind ofPilgrims Choice M…kind ofPilgrims Choice E…kind ofPilgrims Choice V…kind of🪨Hard cheeseskind of🧀Cheddartowardia.com
Main links. Click a topic to open it.

How it connects to Cheese

Pilgrims Choice Cheddar → kind of → 🧀 Cheddar → kind of → 🧀 Cheese

Frequently asked questions

How does Mature differ from Vintage in Pilgrims Choice Cheddar?

Vintage is aged longer: firmer, deeper in flavour, with calcium lactate crystals.

Is Pilgrims Choice cheddar suitable for vegetarians?

Yes, according to the brand all Pilgrims Choice ingredients are suitable for vegetarians.

Similar

Pilgrims Choice Lighter · Pilgrims Choice Sandwich Slices · Cabot Lite · Kerrygold Skellig · Cathedral City Lactose Free · Cathedral City Lighter

Sources

All topics